All existing subsea piping & equipment are always designed for sour service, i.e. NACE compliant. The only places, where NACE specifications must be met on existing topsides facilities, are those places where the increase to 230 ppm H2S would increase hydrogen sulfide partial pressure to more than 0.05 psia. All material used in existing process piping and equipment should be NACE compliant (including all carbon steel and stainless steel). Therefore; the only NACE compliance issue is whether the welds in those areas are NACE compliant.
Welds in those areas need to be audited to “make sure they are NACE compliant.” To do that, “Welding Procedures” and the “Weld Map” must be examined for each weld in those areas.
Two options exist for each weld found to be out of compliance:
- Field heat treat stress relieve, or
- Perform a weld audit; identify non-NACE compliant welds that were made in process systems that operate above 202 psig; cut those welds out; and re-weld in compliance with NACE.
(Note: Corrosion monitoring is NOT applicable because corrosion is not the issue. It is hydrogen induced cracking)
However, destructive testing required to confirm field heat treat stress relief will bring substantial direct costs, and prolonged production downtime probably eliminates Option 1, relative to Option 2. The only other conceivable alternative to either option might be to change the design requirements. Regardless, performance of the weld audit and choice of option to address non-compliant welds must be taken to address this potential failure.
Consequences for not addressing this issue can include hydrogen induced cracking and catastrophic failure in materials in process systems, pressurized above 202 psig, that were not welded in compliance with NACE.